Virtue

From Cor ad Cor
Jump to navigation Jump to search

Virtue is "a habitual and firm disposition to do good" (CCC #1833).

Buddha (~500 BC in India), Confucius (~500 BC in China), Aristotle (~350 BC in Greece), and the classic Christian tradition all hold that "Virtue is the mean between extremes."

"But not every action...admits of a mean; for some have names that already imply badness...adultery, theft, murder; for all of these are themselves bad, and not the excess or deficiencies of them. It is not possible then ever to be right with regard to them; one must always be wrong. ... However they are done they are wrong" (Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics). Catholic philosophy calls such actions "intrinsically evil." The evil of the action cannot be remedied by good intentions nor justified by circumstances. The prohibition of such evildoing is absolute: Do not murder, do not commit adultery, do not lie, do not steal.

Cardinal Virtues

Aristotle developed the theory that there are four cardinal ("hinge") virtues (powers developed by habitual practice) necessary for the good life. The four cardinal virtues interact with each other and support each other.

Prudence

Prudence is wisdom about practical matters. The virtue of prudence enables us to apply general rules to particular situations in which there is no universal negative prohibition to guide us. In such cases, "let your conscience be your guide." Do what you think is best in the circumstances, trusting in God's compassion, mercy, and providence.

Justice

Give to each what each deserves. Treat equals equally; treat unequals unequally.

Fortitude (patience, endurance)

"A few moments of patience now will spare me a hundred days of regret."

Patience is not just a virtue. Patience is the backbone of all other virtues, both natural and supernatural. If we are not patient, we will not be prudent, just, temperate, faithful, hopeful, or loving for very long.

"Beware the persistent man." Without wisdom and justice, fortitude is bull-headed, bigoted, arrogant, and rude (e.g., cranks in science and trolls in Usenet newsgroups).

There are no shortcuts to patience.

Moderation (temperance)

"Moderation in all things" (except sin!).

"Virtue is the mean between extremes."

Too Little Four Cardinal Virtues Too Much
Imprudence Prudence
practical wisdom
Over-caution
Immorality Justice
equal rights, due process
Scrupulosity
Self-indulgence Temperance
moderation
Puritanism/Jansenism
Cowardice Fortitude
courage, endurance
Presumption, arrogance, rage

Seven Deadly Sins

Flip Side Positive Value Seven Deadly Sins
Depression, Despair, Suicide Self-esteem Pride
Dissolution Productivity Greed
Apathy, Frigidity, Impotence Intimacy Lust
Victim Mentality, Passive Aggression Self-defense, Assertiveness Anger
Anorexia Survival, Pleasure Gluttony
Antipathy, Isolation Admiration Envy
Obsessive-compulsion Rest Sloth

Supernatural Virtues

The Theological virtues of faith, hope, and love build on the natural virtues of prudence, justice, temperance, and fortitude. "Grace co-operates with nature."

Deficiency Virtue Excess
Hardness of heart Faith

Fideism,
super-spirituality,
Quietism,
unbalanced enthusiasm

Despair Hope Presumption
Self-centeredness,

Lust

Love Co-dependence,

imprudent, self-destructive giving